No, these discussions further prove that you guys have West Virginia taste. You don't have the trained eye. You see Avril and see the green and pink hair, punk outfits, and the emo makeup, similar to this:
I see great facial structure and a kick-ass little body just waiting to be naked:
If she, not dressed in her punk outfits and emo makeup, were to walk into a restaurant, the entire place would think "damn, that girl is fvcking hot."
Since you can't see what's underneath the clothes and makeup, you aren't able to see that, so calling her "underrated" seems absurd to you.
But lets test my theory again: we already went over JR Rotem dating her, who has also dated other prime hot slvts. Who else did Avril date? She dated Brody Jenner, one of Hollywood's biggest playboys. Around the same years, who had he also dated? Smokeshow Kristin Cavallari (now the wife of Jay Cutler); smokeshow Lauren Conrad; smokeshow and Playmate Jayde Nicole; smokeshow Paris Hilton; smokeshow and Playmate Bryana Holly; smokeshow and Playmate Cora Skinner. Now, if you don't think Avril is good looking and severely underrated, do you think a guy who has had a long history of dating Playmates and famous smokeshows would suddenly date her?