ADVERTISEMENT

FOOTBALL GAME THREAD App State

There is not one position group that is mediocre much less good
We are a bad team in all phases. The defense that probably retained some of Guidry's techniques during the first few games, now looks out of position and lost in the new DC's system. The offense has been a convoluted mess for years.
 
3 or 4 Appalachian State defenders around the receiver and Fancher goes ahead and throws it for his 3 interception of the game. Huff sticking with him no matter how bad he plays
 
Grade the seasons -

2021 - C- First year grace. Returned most of a 7-3 team. No division title, bowl loss, 7-6 final record.

2022 - B . Win over ND like killing the mid term but finishing 5-3 in conference like getting a C on the final.

2023 - D so far, could win out to get to a C, but already guaranteed to have a worse conference record than last year. Regression on offense and defense. Lose out and the VT win is the only bright spot that keeps the F off the sheet.

Overall to date, C-. Those grades plus a lack of underclass talent.
 
Grade the seasons -

2021 - C- First year grace. Returned most of a 7-3 team. No division title, bowl loss, 7-6 final record.

2022 - B . Win over ND like killing the mid term but finishing 5-3 in conference like getting a C on the final.

2023 - D so far, could win out to get to a C, but already guaranteed to have a worse conference record than last year. Regression on offense and defense. Lose out and the VT win is the only bright spot that keeps the F off the sheet.

Overall to date, C-. Those grades plus a lack of underclass talent.
Im going to give Guidry most of the credit for 2022 and a lot of 2021. Of course Huff did hire him so there is that.
 
Coaching matters! Guidry was the magic with the wins & we miss Morrissey too.
 
There will be no changes to the coaching staff next year. Complete turnover via the portal, lots of rah rah in the summer and another face plant. I’m afraid we have one more year of mediocrity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sluggo72
There will be no changes to the coaching staff next year. Complete turnover via the portal, lots of rah rah in the summer and another face plant. I’m afraid we have one more year of mediocrity.
Mediocrity? Think you mean adject failure.
 
Ask him yourself and I'm sure that OC Trickett will tell you that he uses EVERY play in his one and a quarter page Playbook in EVERY HERD GAME!!!
When the QB is as limited as ours, how big can your call sheet be?
Additionally, the OL limits the options. The BU RB is only adequate.
Having exactly one HR threat limits an OC...and even if there was a game wrecker at WR, who'd get him the ball downfield?

Trickett didn't exactly cover himself in glory calling this game. His 2nd down calls were atrocious.
But the main problem with the 'play calling' is that the tactics & strategy are limited by the personnel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: W-S HerdFan
When the QB is as limited as ours, how big can your call sheet be?
Additionally, the OL limits the options. The BU RB is only adequate.
Having exactly one HR threat limits an OC...and even if there was a game wrecker at WR, who'd get him the ball downfield?

Trickett didn't exactly cover himself in glory calling this game. His 2nd down calls were atrocious.
But the main problem with the 'play calling' is that the tactics & strategy are limited by the personnel.
Agree - the stubbornness to change is troubling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: W-S HerdFan
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT