ADVERTISEMENT

All quiet in Huntington

ohio herd

ohio herd

Platinum Buffalo
Gold Member
Aug 28, 2012
9,657
5,744
113
Well since Huff continues this ridiculous blackout of spring practice I will offer this as a point of discussion .This year we have a more challenging schedule it would appear at least on paper. So with that in mind, I would love to hear your thoughts on how well we should do. What makes you think we can win a Sun Belt title this year? IMO we are toast if Fancher doesn't improve or if Pennington or Harrison cant push him for playing time. Ali is a tremendous RB and Payne and Turner will give us 2 quality backups to give him a break. Last year our OL started well then struggled in the middle but seemed to slowly get better as the season played out. Not sure what to expect this year. How are the #2's looking?I mean we are one injury away from "next man up." I really have no idea about the talent of the #2's. With the departure of Gammage how are we looking in the WR corp? Will the defense continue to be a strength again? Huffs second recruiting class didn't even rank in the Top 100 on Rivals. Do we have quality kids in the class. Who is a newbie who can come in and play immediately?
 
I can see the floor being 4-8 and the ceiling being 9-3.

As you pointed out we have a tougher schedule. On the road at ECU will be no cake walk, VT will be tough even though I think we win (I think it will play out like Purdue 2015), at NCST is going to be tough, and we have to play at Coastal, Appy, and S. Alabama.

Then you have to take into account all the question marks we have going into this off season.

1. We have a new DC. I know he said he wants to continue what Guidry was doing, but he's still a different coach who is going to see and call the game differently. How well can he do that.

2. The QB situation is anything but solid right now. Fancher did not look like a championship level QB at any point last season. Has he improved and by just how much. Can one of the freshman push him for the spot and is Coach Huff willing to turn the reigns over to a freshman if they look better than Cam?

3. The OL was suspect in just about every game following ND last year. Can they improve? Especially in pass protection.

4. We lost our only true #1 WR to the portal. Sure we have some talented players, but none have shown they can be the guy that takes the focus of the opposing DC.

5. Can the TEs finally start getting involved in the passing game. If they continue to only account for 10% of the total receptions we will continue struggle to move the ball and score efficiently.

6. Is Ali 100% and if he is who is going to step up to help shoulder the load so we don't run him into the ground like we did Devon Johnson back in 2015.

7. We lost some really good players off of the defense. We also returned and added a few. Can this unit come close to continuing the dominance from last year.

8. Do we have a kicker? 65% on field goals isn't going to get the job done.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Catfanatic1979v1, 31Herd55 and ohio herd
BleedsGreen33 said:
I can see the floor being 4-8 and the ceiling being 9-3.

As you pointed out we have a tougher schedule. On the road at ECU will be no cake walk, VT will be tough even though I think we win (I think it will play out like Purdue 2015), at NCST is going to be tough, and we have to play at Coastal, Appy, and S. Alabama.

Then you have to take into account all the question marks we have going into this off season.

1. We have a new DC. I know he said he wants to continue what Guidry was doing, but he's still a different coach who is going to see and call the game differently. How well can he do that.

2. The QB situation is anything but solid right now. Fancher did not look like a championship level QB at any point last season. Has he improved and by just how much. Can one of the freshman push him for the spot and is Coach Huff willing to turn the reigns over to a freshman if they look better than Cam?

3. The OL was suspect in just about every game following ND last year. Can they improve? Especially in pass protection.

4. We lost our only true #1 WR to the portal. Sure we have some talented players, but none have shown they can be the guy that takes the focus of the opposing DC.

5. Can the TEs finally start getting involved in the passing game. If they continue only account for 10% of the total receptions we will continue struggle to move the ball and score efficiently.

6. Is Ali 100% and if he is who is going to step up to shoulder the load so we don't run him into the ground like we did Devon Johnson back in 2015.

7. We lost some really good players off of the defense. We also returned and added a few. Can this unit come close to continuing the dominance from last year.

8. Do we have a kicker? 65% on field goals isn't going to get the job done.
Click to expand...
I forgot about the new DC. Hopefully we don't miss a beat..... has he ever been a DC before?
 
Just giving the schedule a look and seeing what the teams on our slate did last year and what they have coming back... I could see the Herd finishing anywhere from 4-8 to 10-2. Too many variables with the portal, you never know who is going to step in at another program and light it up right away.

Here is the best case scenario IMO...

Albany -- FCS team at home (W)
ECU -- Pirates had a good year last year, but lost a ton on offense including a 3-year starter at QB. (W)
Virginia Tech -- Coming off a terrible year by their standards and likely still starting Wells at QB. (W)
Old Dominion -- Lost their best offensive weapon, we struggle with them every year, but pull it out. (W)
NC State -- Too much of a talent gap, on the road. (L)
Georgia State -- Always have athletes, never seem to put it together. (W)
James Madison -- Don't love the matchup but its in Huntington. (W)
Coastal Carolina -- Probably the best roster in the East, on the road. (L)
App State -- Coming off a terrible year by their standards, could bounce back, could not. (W)
Georgia Southern -- Can score 50 any game, can give up 51 any game, in Huntington (W)
South Alabama -- Another team that lost their entire offense from last year, like 8 guys. (W)
Arkansas State -- Worst team in SBC, at home. (W)
 
  • Like
Reactions: KellyGreenAlumni, TwolfHerdfan, Bison-4-life and 1 other person
RhinoD said:
Just giving the schedule a look and seeing what the teams on our slate did last year and what they have coming back... I could see the Herd finishing anywhere from 4-8 to 10-2. Too many variables with the portal, you never know who is going to step in at another program and light it up right away.

Here is the best case scenario IMO...

Albany -- FCS team at home (W)
ECU -- Pirates had a good year last year, but lost a ton on offense including a 3-year starter at QB. (W)
Virginia Tech -- Coming off a terrible year by their standards and likely still starting Wells at QB. (W)
Old Dominion -- Lost their best offensive weapon, we struggle with them every year, but pull it out. (W)
NC State -- Too much of a talent gap, on the road. (L)
Georgia State -- Always have athletes, never seem to put it together. (W)
James Madison -- Don't love the matchup but its in Huntington. (W)
Coastal Carolina -- Probably the best roster in the East, on the road. (L)
App State -- Coming off a terrible year by their standards, could bounce back, could not. (W)
Georgia Southern -- Can score 50 any game, can give up 51 any game, in Huntington (W)
South Alabama -- Another team that lost their entire offense from last year, like 8 guys. (W)
Arkansas State -- Worst team in SBC, at home. (W)
Click to expand...
Rhino I hope you are right on this one, I'm not that optimistic yet
 
RhinoD said:
Virginia Tech -- Coming off a terrible year by their standards and likely still starting Wells at QB. (W)
Click to expand...

Yea. I too see this as a W. As I posted above I see this being exactly like VT. Grant is going to be trying way too hard in this game just because he's coming back to Huntington.

VT's roster is a shell of what it was during the Beamer era. I see this game being uncomfortably close for VT and Grant will start forcing things late in the game and turns the ball over once or twice. One of which will results in points. We win by a 3-9 point margin.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ohio herd
RhinoD said:
Albany -- FCS team at home (W)
ECU -- Pirates had a good year last year, but lost a ton on offense including a 3-year starter at QB. (W)
Virginia Tech -- Coming off a terrible year by their standards and likely still starting Wells at QB. (W)
Old Dominion -- Lost their best offensive weapon, we struggle with them every year, but pull it out. (W)
NC State -- Too much of a talent gap, on the road. (L)
Georgia State -- Always have athletes, never seem to put it together. (W)
James Madison -- Don't love the matchup but its in Huntington. (W)
Coastal Carolina -- Probably the best roster in the East, on the road. (L)
App State -- Coming off a terrible year by their standards, could bounce back, could not. (W)
Georgia Southern -- Can score 50 any game, can give up 51 any game, in Huntington (W)
South Alabama -- Another team that lost their entire offense from last year, like 8 guys. (W)
Arkansas State -- Worst team in SBC, at home. (W)
Click to expand...
Geezus . . .

did Perkins hack your account, or what?
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: GoHerdMarshallYes, mlblack16. and BleedsGreen33
BleedsGreen33 said:
I can see the floor being 4-8 and the ceiling being 9-3.

As you pointed out we have a tougher schedule. On the road at ECU will be no cake walk, VT will be tough even though I think we win (I think it will play out like Purdue 2015), at NCST is going to be tough, and we have to play at Coastal, Appy, and S. Alabama.

Then you have to take into account all the question marks we have going into this off season.

1. We have a new DC. I know he said he wants to continue what Guidry was doing, but he's still a different coach who is going to see and call the game differently. How well can he do that.

2. The QB situation is anything but solid right now. Fancher did not look like a championship level QB at any point last season. Has he improved and by just how much. Can one of the freshman push him for the spot and is Coach Huff willing to turn the reigns over to a freshman if they look better than Cam?

3. The OL was suspect in just about every game following ND last year. Can they improve? Especially in pass protection.

4. We lost our only true #1 WR to the portal. Sure we have some talented players, but none have shown they can be the guy that takes the focus of the opposing DC.

5. Can the TEs finally start getting involved in the passing game. If they continue to only account for 10% of the total receptions we will continue struggle to move the ball and score efficiently.

6. Is Ali 100% and if he is who is going to step up to help shoulder the load so we don't run him into the ground like we did Devon Johnson back in 2015.

7. We lost some really good players off of the defense. We also returned and added a few. Can this unit come close to continuing the dominance from last year.

8. Do we have a kicker? 65% on field goals isn't going to get the job done.
Click to expand...
Great questions…but not to be answered by our clandestine coaches
 
  • Like
Reactions: BleedsGreen33
I've said 8-4. If we get improved QB and offensive play, maybe better. We can't expect the D to be as good as last year, lost too many experienced pieces.
Losses to ECU, NC St, Coastal and App. We bring an ND type effort against the Hokies.
 
TwolfHerdfan said:
I've said 8-4. If we get improved QB and offensive play, maybe better. We can't expect the D to be as good as last year, lost too many experienced pieces.
Losses to ECU, NC St, Coastal and App. We bring an ND type effort against the Hokies.
Click to expand...
Year 3 and 8-4 is what we hope for. Considering why we made the coaching move this venture cannot be considered a success if that's where we're at by season's end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HerdFan73, ohio herd and MUMAN3419
BleedsGreen33 said:
Year 3 and 8-4 is what we hope for. Considering why we made the coaching move this venture cannot be considered a success if that's where we're at by season's end.
Click to expand...
We (fans, boosters, etc) want to win league titles... That's why the change was made and you're right, more years of 8-4 isn't the desired result.

Weird football purgatory is difficult to deal with... On one hand, there are a ton of programs that would absolutely love to consistently win 7 to 9 games. On the other, you want to break through and be conference champs at some point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: goherdorgohome2, wvkeeper(HN), W-S HerdFan and 2 others
Then too, Ohio herd, if it gets "too quiet" on here, you could always lead a spirited discussion about all those 4 and 5 star basketball recruits that Danny D. is reeling in almost weekly out of the portal in order to take HERD basketball to the "next level" in the next three seasons!!!
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: ilmherdfan, BleedsGreen33 and W-S HerdFan
Rock98Dog said:
It’s disappointing that we haven’t had a really good QB in 10 years, but WKU can pluck one from the portal every year.
Click to expand...
We haven't had the best coaching either. Look at the offense that WKU runs and look at Doc after Cato and now what Huff is doing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 31Herd55
sluggo72 said:
I'd like a list of these really good QB's the last 10 yrs not named Cato. Chase Litton? Alex Thompson? Birdsong? just wondering
Click to expand...

Well, by you excluding Cato, you're taking away 20% of the years over the last 10 since he was QB in 2013 and 2014. So how many years did we have a really good QB over the last 10?

Cato's last two.

Chase Litton was a really good QB (and statistically for two of his three years). You don't make multiple NFL practice rosters and get pre-season reps without being good.

Grant Wells was a stud QB for us. Did he have turnover issues? Sure. But you don't put up those kind of numbers so early in your career if you aren't a good QB.

Isaiah Green could have been a really good QB with the right guidance.

So out of the last 10, we have had at least six years of good quarterbacks. The inability to get production out of them is on their development and coaching and not their ability.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BleedsGreen33, ohio herd, Marco93 and 2 others
riflearm2 said:
Well, by you excluding Cato, you're taking away 20% of the years over the last 10 since he was QB in 2013 and 2014. So how many years did we have a really good QB over the last 10?

Cato's last two.

Chase Litton was a really good QB (and statistically for two of his three years). You don't make multiple NFL practice rosters and get pre-season reps without being good.

Grant Wells was a stud QB for us. Did he have turnover issues? Sure. But you don't put up those kind of numbers so early in your career if you aren't a good QB.

Isaiah Green could have been a really good QB with the right guidance.

So out of the last 10, we have had at least six years of good quarterbacks. The inability to get production out of them is on their development and coaching and not their ability.
Click to expand...
What are your thoughts on Fancher? Has he peaked yet or do you think he can improve?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 31Herd55
sluggo72 said:
I'd like a list of these really good QB's the last 10 yrs not named Cato. Chase Litton? Alex Thompson? Birdsong? just wondering
Click to expand...
None. We haven't developed a good, multi year starter at QB in forever.
Since Stan Hill, we've had Cato. That's it.

Litton sucked and was a cancer head case. The others were average at best.
 
Fancher is not a good pocket qb. But he has the talent to win football games. I am more disappointed in the coaching than the play of Fancher. You need to use a players talents than try to make him something that he is not or will ever become. Just my thoughts on Fancher.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BleedsGreen33 and TwolfHerdfan
MUMAN3419 said:
Fancher is not a good pocket qb. But he has the talent to win football games. I am more disappointed in the coaching than the play of Fancher. You need to use a players talents than try to make him something that he is not or will ever become. Just my thoughts on Fancher.
Click to expand...
Agree, when rolling out, he is much more effective. It's really on Huff and Trickett to design the scheme to his strengths.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MUMAN3419
Things I like about Fancher --

• He got better as last season went on (until the bowl game)
• He is willing to keep the ball on the read option and can be effective doing so
• He appears to be a "gamer" he got drilled a couple times last year, caught his wind and went right back in

Things Fancher definitely needs to work on --

• His throwing accuracy, especially past 10-12 yards, has been awful
• His grasp of the situation has been lacking at times (throwing to the check down on 3rd/11, 4th down, etc)
• He hasn't shown the ability to make a game-changing play (either throwing or running), relies on long drives
 
  • Like
Reactions: TwolfHerdfan
TwolfHerdfan said:
Litton sucked
Click to expand...

TwolfHerdfan said:
Litton sucked
Click to expand...
2015: 6th most passing yards for all freshman; set Marshall freshman record for TDs and passing yards;
2016: 27th out of 130 QBs for passing yards per game
2017: 31st out of 130 for passing yards

I could go on with more stats, but finishing in the top 25% of the country in most major categories is far from "sucking." And then there's that whole thing about making NFL practice squads, etc.

Did Litton live up to what he could have been? No. Was he a good college QB? Absolutely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ohio herd, 1herdfifteen and BleedsGreen33
riflearm2 said:
2015: 6th most passing yards for all freshman; set Marshall freshman record for TDs and passing yards;
2016: 27th out of 130 QBs for passing yards per game
2017: 31st out of 130 for passing yards

I could go on with more stats, but finishing in the top 25% of the country in most major categories is far from "sucking." And then there's that whole thing about making NFL practice squads, etc.

Did Litton live up to what he could have been? No. Was he a good college QB? Absolutely.
Click to expand...
He was average when you consider no league titles, title games. Did he even make all conference at any point? You know as well as I do, the NFL goes through QB's like water through a sieve. He couldn't even make it in Canada with the CFL. He wasn't bad on the stat side as you pointed out; but his total body of work wouldn't jump out to anyone. jmho.
 
TwolfHerdfan said:
He was average when you consider no league titles, title games. Did he even make all conference at any point? You know as well as I do, the NFL goes through QB's like water through a sieve. He couldn't even make it in Canada with the CFL. He wasn't bad on the stat side as you pointed out; but his total body of work wouldn't jump out to anyone. jmho.
Click to expand...
It takes a team to do that. As @riflearm2 keeps pointing out coaching is a big part of it. The Litton years were some of the most uneven rosters that Doc had during his time here. As I've pointed out several times over, Doc went into cruise control after winning the conference in 2014.

I would also just point out another thing. Since Cato our QBs all suffered from the same issue. Throwing off of their back foot and usually that gets remedied with experience, but it was something the QBs either regressed on or never shook.

I just don't understand why we have dedicated coaches for every position other than QB.

I don't know about Green, but I do believe that both Litton and Wells were extremely talented QBs that never got the right coaching and were damaged goods. I still believe had Litton came back he and Brady were poised to have huge senior seasons and I also believe that Doc and Cramsey ruined Grant when they left him out there flapping in the wind against Rice. We were down two of our starting OL and Adams couldn't move which was getting Grant beat to death and all Cramsey kept doing is dialing up bombs and multiple step drops. He completely forgot that Knox existed.

I don't think Green could digest the playbook well enough to command the offense as he looked completely lost at time and from the moment we recruited him I thought Thomson was a waste of a scholarship.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TwolfHerdfan
MUMAN3419 said:
Fancher is not a good pocket qb. But he has the talent to win football games. I am more disappointed in the coaching than the play of Fancher. You need to use a players talents than try to make him something that he is not or will ever become. Just my thoughts on Fanch
Click to expand...
riflearm2 said:
2015: 6th most passing yards for all freshman; set Marshall freshman record for TDs and passing yards;
2016: 27th out of 130 QBs for passing yards per game
2017: 31st out of 130 for passing yards

I could go on with more stats, but finishing in the top 25% of the country in most major categories is far from "sucking." And then there's that whole thing about making NFL practice squads, etc.

Did Litton live up to what he could have been? No. Was he a good college QB? Absolutely.
Click to expand...
Litton…Mama’s little malcontent…just happy to get another participation trophy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TwolfHerdfan
31Herd55 said:
Litton…Mama’s little malcontent…just happy to get another participation trophy.
Click to expand...
It's odd to me that everyone hated on him and questioned his character and yet Foster was right there with him and no one ever criticized him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

J

Recruiting questions

Replies
27
Views
1K
Old Fairfield - Premium Forum
Teej7
T
ohio herd

After 4 games my take on the Herd

Replies
36
Views
2K
Herd Nation
19MU88
1
R

Graham Harrell

Replies
15
Views
1K
Herd Nation
PeytonwGill
P
R

About last night -- Georgia Southern

Replies
7
Views
722
Old Fairfield - Premium Forum
marshallsig
marshallsig
Chris McLaughlin

HERDNATION.COM Georgia Southern expert gives his take and prediction on Saturday's game

Replies
0
Views
910
Herd Nation
Chris McLaughlin
Chris McLaughlin
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT
Top Bottom
Back