New season, same ole Recruitnik coverage. In recent years, Recruitnik almost always correctly predicts the winner. Rarely is it wrong, however last year it did miss twice. It just continues to prove the fact that more often than not it is more about the Jimmy's and the Joe's than the X's and the O's.
Recruitnik was wrong for a second consecutive week at Bowling Green. This time it was a bad way as the Recruitnik favored Thundering Herd fell to Bowling Green.
Recruitnik is 1 - 2 on the year!
** - Same as last week - Some off the wall numbers before we dive into things: Below is a quick look at the last few recruiting classes, per Rivals, and how they are represented on the depth chart. Note, this does NOT include the transfers.
- 2017 - Only Devin Miller remains
- 2018 - 7 players remain, Corey Gammage, Steven Gilmore, Sam Burton, Talik Keaton, Caleb McMillan, Owen Porter and Dalton Tucker
- 2019 - 9 players still on the roster, 8 on the two deep (Daniel Foster is not listed, but will play) those remaining are Jayshawn Coffman, Esaias Carpenter, Elijah Alston, Micah Abraham, J'coryan Anderson, Eli Neal, Tristen Bittner and EJ Jackson.
-2020 - 9 players remain, 5 on the two deep. Those remaining are Abraham Beauplan, Daytione Smith, Josh Bowers, Charlie Gray and Kerion Martin.
- 2021 - 6 players on the two deep. Charles Montgomery, Cam Fancher, Eric Meeks, Tyshawn Hurst, Ethan Payne and John McConnell.
- 2022 - 1 player on the two deep. There is no chance that anyone would have guessed that the one player to crack the two deep off that star studded class would have been offensive lineman, two star Tariq Montgomery.
**The rules of Recruitnik are simple. We take the two deep depth chart for both teams from the most recent Game Notes put out on their respective Official Athletics Site. We use the Rivals ratings, to the best of our ability, and simply add up the numbers and divide it by the number of players. Who ever has the highest ratings wins. We compare Marshall's offense against the opponents defense, and Marshall's defense against the opponents offense.
*** I was unable to locate the Troy depth chart on their website, I am sure that it was there. I pulled it from another site online, which seemed accurate.
Time to jump right in. The first section will show the unit matchups. Listed below that will be a little more in depth look at a couple important positions.
MARSHALL OFFENSE VS Troy DEFENSE
Marshall is averaging well over 2 overall stars across the offense this season. This includes three former unranked walk on's along the offensive line, all three of which are starting in Ethan Driskell, Logan Osburn and Kendrick Sartor. If those starters were re ranked and came in at two stars then the Herd offense would push an overall 2.5 rating. Marshall's overall offensive rating is being bolstered by former 5 star Florida State running back transfer Khalan Laborn. Four star transfer, also from Florida State, Bryan Robinson helps in that average as he came in with a four star rating.
MARSHALL DEFENSE VS Troy OFFENSE
A former Florida State recruit also helped the defense's overall star rating as Marshall obtained the services of former four star safety Jadarius Green-McKnight. The rest of the defense is fairly consistent with several three star recruits. Like the defense, the overall score includes three transfers from the FCS levels who were unrated out of high school. Two of those players, Andre Sam and Isaiah Norman project as starters and Jace Bobo expects to back up superstar linebacker Abraham Beauplan.
OVERALL MATCHUP
MARSHALL Defensive Backs VS Troy Wide Receivers
Marshall's sefensive backs have been playing very well with Steven Gilmore and Micah Abraham accounting for three interceptions already. Andre Sam and Isaiah Norman are difference making transfers. Coach Huff said this week in his press conference that Troy's wide receivers may be the best we face this year. They have two transfers, one from UAB and one from Kentucky.
MARSHALL DEFENSIVE LINE VS Troy OFFENSIVE LINE
The deepest, and strongest unit on the team has to be the Marshall defensive line. Coach Huff has said multiple times that we went into the bowl game late last season with only 6 healthy defensive lineman. He vowed that would not happen again and the depth chart is a strong indication of that. In addition to the 8 guys listed below, Marshall also lists Emmanuel Balogun, and Jordan Calomese. All 12 players should play each week.
Recruitnik was wrong for a second consecutive week at Bowling Green. This time it was a bad way as the Recruitnik favored Thundering Herd fell to Bowling Green.
Recruitnik is 1 - 2 on the year!
** - Same as last week - Some off the wall numbers before we dive into things: Below is a quick look at the last few recruiting classes, per Rivals, and how they are represented on the depth chart. Note, this does NOT include the transfers.
- 2017 - Only Devin Miller remains
- 2018 - 7 players remain, Corey Gammage, Steven Gilmore, Sam Burton, Talik Keaton, Caleb McMillan, Owen Porter and Dalton Tucker
- 2019 - 9 players still on the roster, 8 on the two deep (Daniel Foster is not listed, but will play) those remaining are Jayshawn Coffman, Esaias Carpenter, Elijah Alston, Micah Abraham, J'coryan Anderson, Eli Neal, Tristen Bittner and EJ Jackson.
-2020 - 9 players remain, 5 on the two deep. Those remaining are Abraham Beauplan, Daytione Smith, Josh Bowers, Charlie Gray and Kerion Martin.
- 2021 - 6 players on the two deep. Charles Montgomery, Cam Fancher, Eric Meeks, Tyshawn Hurst, Ethan Payne and John McConnell.
- 2022 - 1 player on the two deep. There is no chance that anyone would have guessed that the one player to crack the two deep off that star studded class would have been offensive lineman, two star Tariq Montgomery.
**The rules of Recruitnik are simple. We take the two deep depth chart for both teams from the most recent Game Notes put out on their respective Official Athletics Site. We use the Rivals ratings, to the best of our ability, and simply add up the numbers and divide it by the number of players. Who ever has the highest ratings wins. We compare Marshall's offense against the opponents defense, and Marshall's defense against the opponents offense.
*** I was unable to locate the Troy depth chart on their website, I am sure that it was there. I pulled it from another site online, which seemed accurate.
Time to jump right in. The first section will show the unit matchups. Listed below that will be a little more in depth look at a couple important positions.
MARSHALL OFFENSE VS Troy DEFENSE
| Marshall Offense | 2.27 |
| Troy Defense | 2.05 |
| ADVANTAGE | MARSHALL OFFENSE |
MARSHALL DEFENSE VS Troy OFFENSE
| Marshall Defense | 2.09 |
| Troy Offense | 1.95 |
| ADVANTAGE | MARSHALL DEFENSE |
OVERALL MATCHUP
| Marshall Overall Rating | 2.18 |
| Troy Overall Rating | 2.00 |
| ADVANTAGE | MARSHALL |
MARSHALL Defensive Backs VS Troy Wide Receivers
Marshall's sefensive backs have been playing very well with Steven Gilmore and Micah Abraham accounting for three interceptions already. Andre Sam and Isaiah Norman are difference making transfers. Coach Huff said this week in his press conference that Troy's wide receivers may be the best we face this year. They have two transfers, one from UAB and one from Kentucky.
| Marshall | Defensive Backs | Troy | Wide Receivers | ||
| Steven Gilmore | 3 stars | DB | Marcus Rogers | 2 stars | WR |
| Joshua Bowers | 2 stars | DB | RaJae Johnson | 3 stars | WR |
| Andre Sam | 0 stars | DB | Deshon Stoudemire | 2 stars | WR |
| EJ Jackson | 3 stars | DB | Devonte Ross | 3 stars | WR |
| Isaiah Norman | 0 stars | DB | Tez Johnson | 2 stars | WR |
| Jadarius Green-McKnight | 4 stars | DB | Jabre Barber | 2 stars | WR |
| Micah Abraham | 3 stars | DB | Clayton Ollendieck | 0 stars | TE |
| Daytione Smith | 3 stars | DB | Deyunkrea Lewis | 2 stars | TE |
MARSHALL DEFENSIVE LINE VS Troy OFFENSIVE LINE
The deepest, and strongest unit on the team has to be the Marshall defensive line. Coach Huff has said multiple times that we went into the bowl game late last season with only 6 healthy defensive lineman. He vowed that would not happen again and the depth chart is a strong indication of that. In addition to the 8 guys listed below, Marshall also lists Emmanuel Balogun, and Jordan Calomese. All 12 players should play each week.
| Marshall | DL | Koby Cumberlander | 3 | Troy | LT | Austin Stidham | 2 |
| Marshall | DL | Sam Burton | 2 | Troy | LT | Derrick Graham | 2 |
| Marshall | DL | Immanuel Bush | 2 | Troy | LG | Deandre Butler | 2 |
| Marshall | DL | Anthony Watts | 2 | Troy | LG | Kobe Williams | 0 |
| Marshall | DL | Esaias Carpenter | 2 | Troy | C | Jake Andrews | 2 |
| Marshall | DL | Isaiah Gibson | 3 | Troy | C | Jeremiah Frazier | 0 |
| Marshall | DL | Owen Porter | 2 | Troy | RG | Daniel King | 2 |
| Marshall | DL | Elijah Alston | 2 | Troy | RG | Tyler Harvey-Fallows | 2 |
| Troy | RT | Grant Betts | 2 | ||||
| Troy | RT | Daniel King | 2 |
Last edited:
