We are not good in two of the three phases. Doc is supposed to be a super recruiter and is now coaching his 5th senior class of all his players. At some point there should be some level of recognition from the administration that either he is not that great of a recruiter and a bad coach, or that he is a great recruiter and just a horrible coach. It has to be one of the two.
Personally, I think Doc was a good recruiter and just a bad coach, but that has changed. He has gotten very lazy in his recruiting IMO. He has fallen in love with the prop angle and is too focused on picking up guys with talent that the P5 passes on for one reason or another. The problem with that is that to coach kids with issues that make them props probably requires more skill and ability than coaching non prop players. Face it, they are props for a reason. I'm not saying they are dumb, but they aren't A students, so that means they may lack some in the intelligence department, or worse, they lack the commitment or focus to be successful in the classroom. Lacking commitment and focus are never good things.